newsgroups-index (beta)

Current group: sci.math.

Hausdorff Theorem

Hausdorff Theorem  
Martin
 Re: Hausdorff Theorem  
William Elliot
From:Martin
Subject:Hausdorff Theorem
Date:Sun, 23 Jan 2005 23:53:12 +0000 (UTC)


Dear all,


I'm trying to find a proof of the following Hausdorff theorem:

If f is a function on [a,b] and C(f),the set of points of continuity of f, is dense in [a,b], then C(f) is not a set of first category
in [a,b].

As the only reference I have the highly inaccessible Hausdorff's
"Grundz"uge der Mengenlehre" from 1914. I will be most grateful
for any help towards the proof of this important theorem.

Best regards,
Martin
From:William Elliot
Subject:Re: Hausdorff Theorem
Date:Mon, 24 Jan 2005 01:13:10 -0800
From: Martin
Newsgroups: sci.math
Subject: Hausdorff Theorem

> If f is a function on [a,b] and C(f),
> the set of points of continuity of f, is dense in [a,b],
> then C(f) is not a set of first category in [a,b].

C = C(f) is G-delta by theorem for metric spaces, ie
for all n in N, some open U_n with C = /\_n U_n.
Thus
R\C = \/_n R\U_n
int cl R\U_n = int R\U_n subset int R\C = R\cl C = nulset
making R\C sparse, ie 1st category.
So C can't be sparse, otherwise R would be sparse
and you'd be caught by the big Baire.

In general for any topological space X and metric space Y
If f:X -> Y and Y isn't sparse, for example a Baire space,
and if C(f) is dense, then C(f) isn't meager.

Be patient and polite, wait for answer from sci.math,
before rushing off to sci.math.research. Are you a researcher?

----
   

Copyright © 2006 newsgroups-index   -   All rights reserved   -   Impressum